Doctor Assisted Suicide: Is Death the Solution to the Problems of Life?

Posted on December 20th, 2018

Before diving into Doctor Assisted Suicide, let’s revisit a classic illustration of a euphemism.

When you get into an elevator in a tall building and look at the numbers of the floors, what’s missing?  The thirteenth floor!  Of course, the thirteenth floor isn’t missing.  There is no empty space between floors twelve and fourteen.  The thirteenth floor isn’t missing.  It’s called something else, the fourteenth floor.  But you cannot change the reality of a thing by changing the name of the thing.  There still is a thirteenth floor.

Now let’s take this illustration to another level. (Sorry, couldn’t resist!)  Once you accept the lie of calling the thirteenth floor the fourteenth floor, everything after it becomes a lie as well. The fourteenth floor is really the fifteenth floor, the fifteenth floor the sixteenth, and so on.

I was leading a Bible study and talking about the euphemisms for abortion.  We call it a “choice” or a “right” or the “termination of a pregnancy.”  A member of the class stated that the word abortion itself has become a euphemism.  He was right.  We use it so much that it masks the reality behind it.  The reality of an elective abortion is the intentional and brutal killing of an unborn little boy or little girl. We have masked this reality so much that is has led to the other lies.

To solve the problem of a crisis pregnancy, our culture turns to death; killing innocent little boys and girls.  In an attempt to solve the problems caused by horrible diseases like Parkinson’s or Alzheimer’s our culture turns to death, killing tiny little boy and girl embryos for their stem cells.  To solve the problem of pain and suffering our culture turns to death, the sufferer killing him or herself (Doctor Assisted Suicide) or someone else killing the sufferer (Euthanasia).  We established a culture of death by building on the lie that death is an acceptable solution to the problems of life.

Doctor Assisted Suicide (DAS) as an unacceptable solution to the problem human of suffering.  We need this discussion as DAS is becoming more and more acceptable.  Seven states and the District of Columbia now allow DAS.  The majority of other states have DAS legislation at one stage or another.  The number of Americans who have access to DAS went from 13.7 million in 2016 to nearly 55 million at present.  A May 2018 Gallup Poll indicates that 78% of Americans believe doctors should be able to help their terminally ill patients die and 54% believe DAS is morally acceptable.

Formerly known as the Hemlock Society, the group Compassion and Choices actively promotes DAS wherever they are able.  They masterfully euphemize it: “Death with Dignity”  “Aid in Dying” “Compassionate Relief of Suffering”  “Choice in Dying.”  They help craft wording to define away reality.  For example, the Iowa DAS bill states, “the bill shall not, for any purpose, constitute suicide, assisted suicide, mercy killing, or homicide under the law.” (From explanatory Statement of Iowa Senate File introduced Feb. 8 called the “Iowa Death with Dignity Act.”) In other words, this bill legalizing suicide is not about suicide.  (Can you say, “The thirteenth floor is not thirteenth floor”?)

But you cannot change the reality of something by calling it something else.  Suicide is suicide and should be morally unacceptable to American citizens and especially so for those who are Christians and claim the “citizenship of heaven.”

Morally and societally Doctor Assisted Suicide leads to many other problems.  Here are a few.

  • Most suicidal people are depressed. Depression is treatable.  DAS is not that treatment.
  • Pain is treatable. DAS often happens in anticipation of pain, not for the relief of pain.
  • Elder abuse may and has occurred. An attractive inheritance is plenty of reason to encourage or to help grandma take the deadly poison.
  • DAS leads to a “duty to die” mentality. People have been known to take the drugs without any family members knowing because they “did not want to be a burden.”
  • It sends a message, especially to young people, that suicide is a good thing. Studies have shown general suicides increase in states where DAS is legal.
  • DAS as a means of “caring” removes the possibility of true caring. Great advances have been made in palliative care and pain management.
  • Other countries have shown that when it comes to DAS, the “slippery slope” is a reality. The Netherlands, for example, has moved from assisted suicide to euthanasia, from euthanasia for the terminally ill to euthanasia for the chronically ill, from euthanasia for physical distress to euthanasia for psychological distress, from voluntary euthanasia to involuntary euthanasia, and from euthanasia for adults to euthanasia for children.

The above are important things to consider, but for the Christian there are also higher things to consider.  Many in that 54% of Americans who believe DAS is morally acceptable are Christians.  In one sense we can understand that.  Paul does say that “to die is gain” and “to depart and be with Christ is far better” (Philippians 1:21 & 23).  Christians know this to be true.  All our problems, suffering, and disease will be gone when we die and go to heaven. The devil, who is very clever at using the Word of God by the way, uses these words to plant the question, “So, then what’s so wrong with sending grandma to be with Jesus?”  There is nothing wrong with wanting grandma to be with Jesus or to pray that Jesus send His angels to take her to heaven.  But it is not within the scope of our authority to send grandma there.

That’s why we also need to read the very next verse, indeed it completes the sentence of verse 23. “but to remain in the flesh is more necessary on your account” (1:24).  It certainly is “far better” to be with Jesus, but it may be “more necessary” to remain living.  Now the important part—God is in charge of the more necessary.  By the end of this chapter Paul is convinced that he will remain in the flesh and that God has “fruitful labor” left for him to do.  Remember, Paul’s fruitful labor consisted of what God kept doing through Paul, especially working in and through Paul’s weaknesses. “My power is made perfect in weakness” (2 Corinthians 12:9).

Ask any pastor and he will tell you of the “fruitful labor” witnessed in hospital beds, nursing homes, and hospice facilities. Sins confessed and forgiven.  Old wounds healed, and new relationships established. Stories shared that were never heard before.  Blessings given to grandchildren and grandparents being blessed by the very presence of grandchildren.  Even staff coming to faith as they witness the bold and enduring faith of others in the face of death.  The list goes on.

As long as God gives life, He gives life purpose.  As long as God gives life, He is at work producing fruitful labor through that life.

But how do we know for sure that God works in the sufferings of our life as He promises to do? (See Romans 8:28.)  The thesis of this post is that death is not an acceptable solution to the problems of life.  However, there was that one time!  “For the death he died he died to sin once for all . . .” (Romans 6:10a).  We know that God works in the sufferings of our lives according to His will and purpose, because He was at work in the greatest suffering of all time—Jesus suffering God’s wrath for the sins of the world.  Through this greatest suffering came the greatest good, forgiveness of sins and, through Christ’s resurrection from the dead, the certain hope of our own resurrection with perfect, suffering-free bodies living for all eternity in paradise.

We know God works in the suffering of our lives not always because we see His work or feel His work, but because He promises to be at work.  We cling to promises not feelings.  We cling to what is unseen not to what is seen (2 Corinthians 4:13).  We of finite minds dare not interfere with the infinite wisdom of God by thinking we know best when it is time for someone to die.

Now we need to turn the tables a bit.  Servants need people to serve.  The answer I gave to my homebound and nursing home members when asked, “Why is God keeping me around?” was this: “You are Jesus to me.  For the Bible tells me that whatever I do to the least, the vulnerable, to those in need, I do to Him.”  I would tell them that they were Jesus to me and this was a great honor, not only for me, but for them.  When we turn killing into caring, we lose untold opportunities to serve and be Jesus.

As example, consider the contrast between Brittany Maynard and Maggie Karner.  In 2014 both were diagnosed with the same kind of terminal brain cancer.  Brittany produced a YouTube video that garnered may viewers.  She explained why she was moving to Oregon to avail herself to the legality of assisted death.  She wanted to choose the time and manner of her death.  She did not want family and loved ones to see her in what she perceived would be a state of unbearable suffering.

Maggie Karner, former director of LCMS Life Ministries, on the other hand, chose to trust in the “unseen” things God would do.  Allow me to let Maggie, now with her Lord, speak for herself in a series of quotes.

“As a Christian with a Savior who loves me dearly and has redeemed me from a dying world, I have a higher calling.  God wants me to be comfortable on my dependence on Him and others, to live with Him in peace and comfort no matter what comes my way.”

“As for my cancer journey, circumstances out of my control are not the worst thing that could happen to me.  The worst thing would be losing my faith, refusing to trust in God’s purpose in my life and trying to grab that control myself.”

“I’ve had the gift of raising three lovely daughters.  I want my girls to learn selflessness and servanthood as they care for me.”

“[God] truly understands our sorrows and feelings of helplessness.  I want my kids to know that Christ’s resurrection from that borrowed grave confirms that death could not hold Him, and it will not hold me either—a baptized child of God.”

No matter how often you call the thirteenth floor the fourteenth floor, it will remain the thirteenth floor.  No matter how often we call death our friend, an acceptable way of dealing with the problems of life, an acceptable way of “caring” for the dying, death will remain our enemy, the wages of sin.  Turning to death to solve our problems is not good for our culture and it is not true to the faith of a Christian.

We have a better way, Jesus, the One who is the Way, the One who defeated our enemy death and has given us new life and the assurance that He is at work in our lives regardless of our circumstances.  He calls us to care not to kill.  He calls us to serve Him by serving others in their need.  He calls us to be Him by allowing others to serve us in our need.

To Him alone be the glory.

Rev., Dr. James Lamb – Lutheran Family Service Life Advocate

For information about doctor assisted suicide and other life issues, legislative action in Iowa, and the planned Prayer for Life gathering at the capital, visit lutheranfamilyservice.org/outreach/life-advocacy/.